18th Jun 2024 Gemini 1.5 Pro
Manu Caddie begins by painting a stark picture of the environmental degradation plaguing the Tairawhiti region of New Zealand. He argues that decades of prioritizing short-term economic gains over environmental sustainability have led to a crisis point. He specifically criticizes the reliance on pine plantations, which were initially promoted as a solution to soil erosion but have proven disastrous. The heavy, shallow-rooted pines, coupled with unsustainable clear-felling practices, have exacerbated erosion, polluted waterways, and damaged marine ecosystems.
Caddie emphasizes the urgency of the situation, highlighting the region's dependence on these unsustainable industries and the cultural implications of environmental collapse. He draws parallels between the decline of the pine industry and the earlier decline of sheep and beef farming, both of which promised economic prosperity but ultimately proved unsustainable. The current situation, with collapsing plantations and increasingly frequent extreme weather events, threatens livelihoods, cultural identity, and the very ability of people to remain on their ancestral lands.
"In one situation, one plantation in our communities, 4,000 hectares of clear fell pine within a few months on erosion-prone land, and that's caused some massive issues. The slash, we call it, which is the woody waste off the harvest sites, is supposed to stay on the site. Sometimes it's burnt. Generally, they build these sort of bird's nests on the side of the hill but very often the rain comes and the soil slips away underneath those birds nests and the woody debris makes its way into the waterways which is terrible for the aquatic life there and then that makes its way onto the beaches and then into the marine environment."
Caddie sees the concept of degrowth as a potential solution to the interconnected environmental and economic crises facing not just Tairawhiti, but the world. He believes that the prevailing economic paradigm of endless growth on a finite planet is unsustainable. While acknowledging the difficulty of challenging deeply ingrained societal norms around consumption and progress, he stresses the need for adjusting expectations of what constitutes a good life. This, he argues, involves questioning assumptions about material possessions, consumption patterns, and the very definition of a thriving economy.
Caddie recognizes the discomfort and resistance that the idea of degrowth evokes, attributing it to the pervasiveness of the growth-centric mindset. However, he remains hopeful that through open dialogue and the exploration of alternative models, a more sustainable and equitable future is possible. He advocates for a shift in focus from individual gain to collective well-being, prioritizing the long-term health of the planet and future generations over short-term economic gains.
"It's the first time I've heard it where I feel like it's kind of a new way to frame it of just, we need to adjust our expectations. What does it mean to live a good life? We need to adjust our expectations, which I think is, it's a very accessible way to say it. It's like, yeah, well, maybe there's not two cars per household. Maybe there's not that extra kitchen renovation or that extra bedroom out back, or maybe it's not that many flights per year."
Caddie advocates for the exploration of "authentic alternatives" - practical and impactful solutions that challenge the status quo and offer genuine paths towards a more sustainable and equitable future. He emphasizes the need for action that is both grounded in reality and guided by strong ethical principles. He draws inspiration from historical examples like the Catholic Worker Movement, which combined social activism with practical initiatives to address poverty and injustice.
While acknowledging the importance of respectful dialogue and finding common ground, Caddie also recognizes the crucial role of activism in driving societal change. He argues that disrupting the status quo is often necessary to shift public discourse and challenge entrenched power structures. He draws parallels with the Civil Rights Movement, highlighting how tactics once considered radical can, with time, become widely accepted. He encourages support for activists who put themselves on the line, acknowledging the risks they take and the vital role they play in pushing for systemic change.
"And I think it's, what does an authentic alternative look like? Because there's plenty of sort of theoretical alternatives and ideological ones, but However you define authenticity, but it's like sort of something that's practical and real."
Caddie sees significant potential in utilizing New Zealand's rich biodiversity to create sustainable economic opportunities while promoting land regeneration. He discusses his work exploring the medicinal and commercial potential of native plants and fungi, focusing on species like kānuka, which has shown promise in treating skin conditions. He emphasizes the importance of sustainable harvesting practices and ensuring that local communities benefit from the utilization of their natural resources.
Central to Caddie's vision is the idea of indigenous communities maintaining control over the intellectual property rights associated with native species. He criticizes the exploitation of indigenous knowledge and resources for profit by external actors, highlighting the case of mānuka honey as a cautionary tale. He advocates for innovative legal structures that recognize the rights of nature, potentially granting ownership of intellectual property to the species themselves or to entities specifically designed to protect their interests.
"And the challenge there is that it's sort of the horse bolted and ran away from the country and the communities that the plant is based in and got trademarked overseas and things. And so with kānuka, while no one cares about it, we're rushing in to trademark some brands around that and define it ourselves rather than letting the government define what a kānuka product is and making sure that Māori is indigenous products guardians of that species are in control of that process again rather than letting anyone sort of commercialise it and run away with it."
Caddie emphasizes that addressing the environmental and economic challenges facing his community requires more than just technical solutions. He stresses the importance of cultural healing and the revitalization of traditional values and practices. He believes that fostering a strong sense of community, reconnecting with the land, and addressing historical trauma are essential for building a sustainable and resilient future. He sees hope in the younger generation's growing cultural confidence and their willingness to engage with their heritage.
Caddie underscores the importance of extending this approach beyond indigenous communities, advocating for greater understanding and collaboration across cultural divides. He believes that recognizing shared humanity and finding common ground are essential for navigating the complex challenges of the present and creating a more just and sustainable world for all. He concludes by emphasizing the importance of open, honest, and sometimes uncomfortable conversations in bridging divides and fostering understanding.
"But, you know, we're seeing really amazing progress, language revitalization and cultural regeneration happening in a new generation that doesn't have the same pain and hurts. Um, there's been a break and a severing of some of that trauma, I think just in the last couple of, you know, generation, perhaps. And so our children sort of, you know, think it's strange that we get so upset about certain injustices and things because it's not a big deal for them. They are confident in their own skin and their culture and they've got their language and they haven't necessarily known the struggle, but they also respect that those that have gone before have had that struggle."
Airtable