Goodreads

Ivan Illich's "Tools for Conviviality" is a critique of the industrial mode of production and its destructive effects on human life and society. He argues that the relentless pursuit of growth, efficiency, and technological advancement has led to a set of interconnected crises that threaten our very existence.

The book identifies six major areas of imbalance caused by the overgrowth of tools:

1. Biological Degradation: Industrialization is damaging the environment, threatening the delicate balance between humanity and the biosphere.
2. Radical Monopoly: Industrialized production processes create monopolies that restrict choices and replace individual competence with dependence on large institutions.
3. Overprogramming: The industrialization of learning, through schooling and mass media, suppresses creativity and fosters dependence on pre-defined knowledge and information.
4. Polarization: Industrialization leads to a growing gap between rich and poor, exacerbating social inequalities and concentrating power in the hands of a few.
5. Obsolescence: Constant innovation and product development fueled by the ideology of progress create a cycle of waste and dependence, undermining traditional values and societal stability.
6. Frustration: The pursuit of ever-increasing efficiency and satisfaction through industrial means leads to a pervasive sense of frustration and a feeling of being trapped by the very systems meant to serve us.

Illich proposes a "convivial society" as an alternative, characterized by:

• Limited tools: A focus on tools that empower individuals and communities, rather than those designed for mass production and consumption.
• Decentralized production: Emphasis on self-reliance, local production, and personal competence, reducing dependence on large institutions.
• Austerity and sobriety: A rejection of the ideology of endless growth and a recognition of the value of simple living and sustainable practices.
• Self-determined learning: Promoting autonomous learning, encouraging exploration and questioning, and moving away from formal schooling as the sole source of knowledge.
• Participatory justice: Equalizing power and control over resources, ensuring that individuals and communities have the freedom to shape their own lives and environments.

To achieve this convivial society, Illich argues for a political inversion, involving:

• Demythologizing science: Reframing science as a personal activity of exploration and questioning, rather than an authoritative source of objective knowledge.
• Rediscovering language: Reclaiming language from the domination of industrial production, using it to promote individual agency and shared values.
• Recovering legal procedure: Utilizing the formal structures of law and politics to set limits on the power of institutions and protect individual liberties.

The book emphasizes the importance of shared understanding and action, highlighting the power of individuals and communities to bring about change through a conscious process of political inversion. It is a call to reclaim our agency and reject the seductive but ultimately destructive path of endless industrial growth.